| Year | Class | Individual Runner-Up | Score | Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Division II | Simone Guyton Harding Academy |
167-181 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2024 | Division I | Kenzie Bond Bartlett |
150-193 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2023 | Division II | Kyla Mitchell Boyd Buchanan |
181-191 | Smyrna Bowilng Center |
| 2023 | Division I | Millie Bromley Hardin County |
171-182 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2022 | Division II | Tori Moore St. Benedict |
168-222 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2022 | Division I | Macy Bromley Hardin County |
188-199 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2021 | Division II | Jenna Hedgepath Lipscomb Academy |
147-169 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2021 | Division I | Elizabeth Coutta Smyrna |
162-200 | Smyrna Bowilng Center |
| 2020 | Division II | Olivia VanHooser Friendship Christian |
166-197 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2020 | Division I | Kyleigh Husted White House |
189-201 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2019 | Division I | Kailee Channell Hardin County |
214-221 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2019 | Division II | Emily Wilson St. Agnes |
128-199 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2018 | Division II | Ashton Bazzell Baylor |
127-174 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2018 | Division I | Danielle Jedlicki Siegel |
213-252 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2017 | Division II | Grace Becker St. Agnes |
133-154 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2017 | Division I | Baleigh Snow Blackman |
201-245 | Smyrna Bowing Center |
| 2016 | Division I | Danielle Jedlicki Siegel |
189 (40) - 189 (49) | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2016 | Division II | Grace Becker St. Agnes |
137-164 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2015 | Division II | Megan Wilson St. Agnes |
184-192 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2015 | Division I | Kenzie Bowman Upperman |
171-183 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2014 | Division I | McKenna Shaffer Sevier County |
163-173 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2014 | Division II | Morgan Bryant St. Benedict |
140-201 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2013 | Division II | Sara Griffith Girls Preparatory School |
1743 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2013 | Division I | Chelsie Cleaves White Station |
2638 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2012 | Division II | Miranda Mott Ensworth |
1824 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2012 | Division I | Emily Nykiel Collierville |
2772 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2011 | Division I | Brandi Caruso John Overton |
2641 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2011 | Division II | Angela Vick St. Benedict |
1771 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2010 | Division I | Lauren Adams White Station |
2643 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2010 | Division II | Alexis Lucus St. Benedict |
1807 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2009 | Division II | Tori Henson St. Agnes |
1702 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2009 | Division I | Kim Qualls Hardin County |
2671 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2008 | Division II | Hayley Pionk Pope John Paul II |
1652 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2008 | Division I | Hilary Bell Soddy-Daisy |
2615 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2007 | Division II | Christina Calvo Pope John Paul II |
1682 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2007 | Division I | Maia Zaykova Donelson Christian Academy |
2588 | Smyrna Bowling Center |