| Year | Class | Team Runner-Up | Score | Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Class A-AA | Station Camp | 122 | Sanders Ferry Park |
| 2023 | Class AAA | Hardin Valley | 136 | Sanders Ferry Park |
| 2023 | Division II A | University School of Nashville | 74 | Sanders Ferry Park |
| 2023 | Division II AA | Harpeth Hall | 62 | Sanders Ferry Park |
| 2022 | Class A-AA | Murfreesboro Central Magnet | 100 | Sanders Ferry Park |
| 2022 | Class AAA | Beech | 91 | Sanders Ferry Park |
| 2022 | Division II A | Webb School - Bell Buckle | 66 | Sanders Ferry Park |
| 2022 | Division II AA | Webb School of Knoxville | 98 | Sanders Ferry Park |
| 2021 | Class A-AA | Signal Mountain | 58 | Sanders Ferry Park |
| 2021 | Class AAA | Farragut | 96 | Sanders Ferry Park |
| 2021 | Division II A | University School of Nashville | 83 | Sanders Ferry Park |
| 2021 | Division II AA | Webb School of Knoxville | 73 | Sanders Ferry Park |
| 2020 | Small Class | Merrol Hyde | 156 | Sanders Ferry Park |
| 2020 | Large Class | Farragut | 112 | Sanders Ferry Park |
| 2020 | Division II A | Webb School of Knoxville | 66 | Sanders Ferry Park |
| 2020 | Division II AA | Father Ryan | 123 | Sanders Ferry Park |
| 2019 | Small Class | University School Johnson City | 119 | Percy Warner |
| 2019 | Large Class | Brentwood | 95 | Percy Warner |
| 2019 | Division II A | Webb School of Knoxville | 81 | Percy Warner |
| 2019 | Division II AA | Harpeth Hall | 110 | Percy Warner |
| 2018 | Small Class | University School Johnson City | 99 | Percy Warner |
| 2018 | Large Class | Farragut | 155 | Percy Warner |
| 2018 | Division II A | St. George's | 98 | Percy Warner |
| 2018 | Division II AA | Harpeth Hall | 58 | Percy Warner |
| 2017 | Small Class | White House Heritage | 94 | Percy Warner |
| 2017 | Large Class | Houston | 132 | Percy Warner |
| 2017 | Division II A | University School of Nashville | 68 | Percy Warner |
| 2017 | Division II AA | Brentwood Academy | 69 | Percy Warner |
| 2016 | Class A-AA | Knoxville Catholic | 97 | Percy Warner |
| 2016 | Class AAA | Dobyns Bennett | 105 | Percy Warner |
| 2016 | Division II A | University School of Nashville | 52 | Percy Warner |
| 2016 | Division II AA | Girls Preparatory School | 63 | Percy Warner |
| 2015 | Class A-AA | Christian Academy of Knoxville | 59 | Percy Warner |
| 2015 | Class AAA | Brentwood | 97 | Percy Warner |
| 2015 | Division II A | University School of Nashville | 57 | Percy Warner |
| 2015 | Division II AA | Baylor | 72 | Percy Warner |
| 2014 | Class A-AA | Christian Academy of Knoxville | 78 | Percy Warner |
| 2014 | Class AAA | Houston | 124 | Percy Warner |
| 2014 | Division II A | University School of Nashville | 59 | Percy Warner |
| 2014 | Division II AA | Brentwood Academy | 80 | Percy Warner |
| 2013 | Class A-AA | Christian Academy of Knoxville | 80 | Percy Warner |
| 2013 | Class AAA | Brentwood | 116 | Percy Warner |
| 2013 | Division II AA | Harpeth Hall | 70 | Percy Warner |
| 2013 | Division II A | St. Cecilia | 37 | Percy Warner |
| 2012 | Class A-AA | Macon County | 100 | Percy Warner |
| 2012 | Class AAA | Siegel | 149 | Percy Warner |
| 2012 | Division II A | University School of Nashville | 87 | Percy Warner |
| 2012 | Division II AA | Brentwood Academy | 63 | Percy Warner |
| 2011 | Class A-AA | Greeneville | 115 | Percy Warner |
| 2011 | Class AAA | Science Hill | 119 | Percy Warner |
| 2011 | Division II A | Webb School of Knoxville | 56 | Percy Warner |
| 2011 | Division II AA | St. Benedict | 78 | Percy Warner |
| 2010 | Class A-AA | Hume Fogg | 115 | Percy Warner |
| 2010 | Class AAA | Science Hill | 117 | Percy Warner |
| 2010 | Division II A | St. Cecilia | 57 | Percy Warner |
| 2010 | Division II AA | St. Agnes | 78 | Percy Warner |
| 2009 | Class A-AA | Trinity Christian | 100 | Percy Warner |
| 2009 | Class AAA | Knoxville Catholic | 102 | Percy Warner |
| 2009 | Division II A | University School of Jackson | 96 | Percy Warner |
| 2009 | Division II AA | Ensworth | 88 | Percy Warner |
| 2008 | Class A-AA | Knoxville Catholic | 109 | Percy Warner |
| 2008 | Division II A | Harding Academy | 29 | Percy Warner |
| 2008 | Division II AA | Brentwood Academy | 51 | Percy Warner |
| 2008 | Class AAA | Oak Ridge | 58 | Percy Warner |
| 2007 | Class A-AA | Jackson Christian | 109 | Percy Warner |
| 2007 | Class AAA | Science Hill | 102 | Percy Warner |
| 2007 | Division II AA | Ensworth | 75 | Percy Warner |
| 2007 | Division II A | Harding Academy | 37 | Percy Warner |
| 2006 | Class A-AA | David Lipscomb | 63 | Percy Warner |
| 2006 | Class AAA | Oak Ridge | 94 | Percy Warner |
| 2006 | Division II | Harpeth Hall | 83 | Percy Warner |
| 2005 | Class A-AA | Chattanooga Christian | 90 | Percy Warner |
| 2005 | Class AAA | Houston | 109 | Percy Warner |
| 2005 | Division II | Webb School of Knoxville | 85 | Percy Warner |
| 2004 | Class A-AA | Chattanooga Christian | 97 | Percy Warner |
| 2004 | Class AAA | Morristown West | 70 | Percy Warner |
| 2004 | Division II | Girls Preparatory School | 82 | Percy Warner |
| 2003 | Class A-AA | Happy Valley | 74 | Percy Warner |
| 2003 | Division II | Brentwood Academy | 65 | Percy Warner |
| 2003 | Class AAA | White Station | 104 | Percy Warner |
| 2002 | Class A-AA | Sullivan Central | 111 | Percy Warner |
| 2002 | Class AAA | Farragut | 90 | Percy Warner |
| 2002 | Division II | Girls Preparatory School | 81 | Percy Warner |
| 2001 | Class A-AA | Sullivan Central | 87 | Percy Warner |
| 2001 | Division II | Brentwood Academy | 62 | Percy Warner |
| 2001 | Class AAA | Farragut | 84 | Percy Warner |
| 2000 | Class A-AA | David Lipscomb | 105 | Percy Warner |
| 2000 | Class AAA | Oak Ridge | 83 | Percy Warner |
| 2000 | Division II | Girls Preparatory School | 75 | Percy Warner |
| 1999 | Class AAA | Houston | 120 | Percy Warner |
| 1999 | Class A-AA | Hume Fogg | 74 | Percy Warner |
| 1999 | Division II | Baylor | 60 | Percy Warner |
| 1998 | Class AAA | Oak Ridge | 94 | Percy Warner |
| 1998 | Class A-AA | Chattanooga Christian | 63 | Percy Warner |
| 1998 | Division II | Father Ryan | 49 | Percy Warner |
| 1997 | Class AAA | Oak Ridge | 70 | Percy Warner |
| 1997 | Class A-AA | Hume Fogg | 84 | Percy Warner |
| 1997 | Division II | Girls Preparatory School | 80 | Percy Warner |
| 1996 | Class AAA | Farragut | 90 | Percy Warner |
| 1996 | Class A-AA | Harpeth Hall | 83 | Percy Warner |
| 1995 | Class AAA | Dobyns Bennett | 89 | Percy Warner |
| 1995 | Class A-AA | Harpeth Hall | 104 | Percy Warner |
| 1994 | Class AAA | Morristown West | 60 | Percy Warner |
| 1994 | Class A-AA | Harpeth Hall | 103 | Percy Warner |
| 1993 | Class AAA | Dobyns Bennett | 63 | Percy Warner |
| 1993 | Class A-AA | Brentwood Academy | 67 | Percy Warner |
| 1992 | Class AAA | Farragut | 97 | Percy Warner |
| 1992 | Class A-AA | Girls Preparatory School | 92 | Percy Warner |
| 1991 | Class AAA | Farragut | 70 | Percy Warner |
| 1991 | Class A-AA | Harpeth Hall | 80 | Percy Warner |
| 1990 | Class AAA | Dobyns Bennett | 60 | Percy Warner |
| 1990 | Class A-AA | Brentwood Academy | 67 | Percy Warner |
| 1989 | Brentwood Academy | 85 | Percy Warner | |
| 1988 | Farragut | 50 | Percy Warner | |
| 1987 | Girls Preparatory School | 91 | Percy Warner | |
| 1986 | Girls Preparatory School | 86 | Percy Warner | |
| 1985 | Oak Ridge | 75 | Percy Warner | |
| 1984 | Oak Ridge | 78 | Percy Warner | |
| 1983 | Oak Ridge | 80 | Percy Warner | |
| 1982 | Farragut | 68 | Percy Warner | |
| 1981 | Oak Ridge | 54 | Percy Warner | |
| 1980 | Bishop Byrne | 93 | Percy Warner | |
| 1979 | Germantown | 86 | Percy Warner | |
| 1978 | Memphis Catholic | 95 | Percy Warner | |
| 1977 | Hillsboro | 95 | Percy Warner | |
| 1976 | Tullahoma | 56 | Percy Warner | |
| 1975 | Bearden | 78 | Percy Warner |