| Year | Class | Team Runner-Up | Score | Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Division II | Columbia Academy (11-2) | 5-22 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2024 | Division I | Green Hill (23-2) | 10-5-16.5 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2023 | Division II | Friendship Christian (16-1) | 11-12 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2023 | Division I | Dobyns Bennett (19-1) | 7-16 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2022 | Division II | Pope John Paul II (9-4) | 8-15 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2022 | Division I | Smyrna (23-2) | 9-14 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2021 | Division I | Smyrna (20-4) | 7-20 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2021 | Division II | Pope John Paul II (16-1) | 11-16 | Smyrna Bowing Center |
| 2020 | Division II | Christian Brothers (16-2) | 6-21 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2020 | Division I | Hardin County (20-1) | 8-19 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2019 | Division I | Hardin County (18-1) | 6-21 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2019 | Division II | St. Benedict (15-3) | 9-18 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2018 | Division II | St. Benedict (10-3) | 8-19 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2018 | Division I | White House (20-5) | 11-16 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2017 | Division II | Christian Brothers (16-2) | 9-18 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2017 | Division I | Smyrna (24-1) | 13-14 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2016 | Division II | McCallie (16-6) | 11-16 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2016 | Division I | Smyrna (23-1) | 9-18 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2015 | Division II | McCallie (17-4) | 7-20 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2015 | Division I | Clarksville Academy (21-4) | 7-20 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2014 | Division II | Pope John Paul II (20-7) | 8-19 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2014 | Division I | Walker Valley (28-2) | 9-18 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2013 | Division II | Memphis University School (10-4) | 9-18 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2013 | Division I | Bartlett (23-9) | 6-21 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2012 | Division I | Columbia Central (21-1) | 13-14 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2012 | Division II | Donelson Christian Academy (25-4) | 9-18 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2011 | Division I | Wilson Central (23-2) | 9.5-17.5 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2011 | Division II | St. Benedict (17-1) | 13-14 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2010 | Division I | Soddy-Daisy (20-1) | 5.5-21.5 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2010 | Division II | Donelson Christian Academy (18-2) | 7-20 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2009 | Division II | Battle Ground Academy (19-2) | 10-17 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2009 | Division I | Wilson Central (22-3) | 7-20 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2008 | Division I | Hendersonville (23-2) | 8-19 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2008 | Division II | St. Benedict (15-2) | 12-15 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2007 | Division I | Hardin County (21-5) | 10-17 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2007 | Division II | Christian Brothers (18-1) | 2-25 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2006 | Division II | Christian Brothers (16-2) | 11-16 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2006 | Division I | Hixson (26-2) | 7.5-19.5 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2005 | Division II | Baylor (14-6) | 7-20 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2005 | Division I | Columbia Central (16-3) | 7-20 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2004 | Division II | Montgomery Bell Academy (17-2) | 10-17 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2004 | Division I | Spring Hill (19-2) | 13-14 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2003 | Division II | Father Ryan (18-1) | 7-20 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2003 | Division I | Mt. Juliet (19-4) | 5-22 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2002 | Division II | Father Ryan | 8-19 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2002 | Division I | Soddy-Daisy (24-1) | 10.5-16.5 | Smyrna Bowling Center |