| Year | Class | Individual Runner-Up | Score | Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Division II | Jackson Roberts St. Benedict |
169-223 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2024 | Division I | Matteo Quintero Stewarts Creek |
222-226 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2023 | Division II | Cole Frasure Christian Brothers |
198-203 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2023 | Division I | Sean Reasoner Houston |
182-200 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2022 | Division II | Finn Donnelly Pope John Paul II |
150-224 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2022 | Division I | Gavin Robertson Bartlett |
164-211 | Smyrna Bowing Center |
| 2021 | Division II | Brendan Donlevy Briarcrest |
189-227 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2021 | Division I | Jacob Brown Walker Valley |
197-238 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2020 | Division II | C.J. Petrin Notre Dame |
174-177 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2020 | Division I | Hunter Hardaway Greenbrier |
171-180 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2019 | Division II | C.J. Petrin Notre Dame |
207-210 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2019 | Division I | Jacob Watts White House |
196-235 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2018 | Division II | Jimmy Morrow Memphis University School |
206-234 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2018 | Division I | Xavier Powell-Short Smyrna |
186-237 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2017 | Division II | Jimmy Morrow Memphis University School |
188-212 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2017 | Division I | Cole Flatt Columbia Central |
191-203 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2016 | Division I | Jonathan Colbaugh Columbia Central |
168-246 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2016 | Division II | Bradley Pounds Christian Brothers |
150-185 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2015 | Division II | Conner Nichols St. Benedict |
147-243 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2015 | Division I | Dustin Brakefield Lebanon |
213-226 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2014 | Division I | Aaron Ruiz Cane Ridge |
188-217 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2014 | Division II | Jack Alcott Ensworth |
160-163 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2013 | Division II | Ben Bishop Ensworth |
1740 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2013 | Division I | Aaron Ruiz Cane Ridge |
2974 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2012 | Division II | Casey Pope Battle Ground Academy |
1970 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2012 | Division I | Chase Smith Hardin County |
2935 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2011 | Division II | Houston Thomas Donelson Christian Academy |
1880 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2011 | Division I | Dylan Woods Lawrence County |
2913 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2010 | Division I | Justin Miller Greeneville |
2826 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2010 | Division II | Justin Turner Donelson Christian Academy |
1906 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2009 | Division II | Alex Goss McCallie |
1870 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2009 | Division I | Matt Lyon Soddy-Daisy |
2823 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2008 | Division II | Rand Woodson Montgomery Bell Academy |
1844 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2008 | Division I | Gary Faulkner Germantown |
2899 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2007 | Division II | Cliff Harrington Christian Brothers |
1866 | Smyrna Bowling Center |
| 2007 | Division I | Garrett Flatt Columbia Central |
2797 | Smyrna Bowling Center |